|
Post by Chugoku-jinko on Jul 18, 2009 1:32:00 GMT -5
I have a question regarding Detective Conan vs Lupin III Special. I hope I'm posting in the right section. How did Lupin III found out that Edogawa Conan is really Shinichi Kudo? With all your knowledge and connections, I hope you could enlighten me on this. The last scene really stunned me. I never expected that kind of ending. i'm not quite sure how he found out about conana's idenity either. i just knew that lupin thought conan had a very abnormal behavior/mentallity than a regular 7 year old boy
|
|
|
Post by iAnanoC on Aug 5, 2009 20:16:46 GMT -5
Question: "Gosho Aoyama, why bother putting AiConan "moments" in the series just to give ConanAi false hope [because we all know for sure (because it's so always unbearably being implied... AGAIN... and AGAIN... and AGAIN) that Shinichi/Conan would end up with unicorn--I mean... Ran] if it's not going to happen?" "Why bother make Ai Haibara a GIRL? ShinRan fans just seem to LOVE debating how Ai could NEVER EVER be with Shinichi/Conan because he has the beautiful and all-the-time amiable Ran Mouri; they seem to be "jealous" of the "relationship" Conan and Ai have; wouldn't it be so much more simpler if Ai were a BOY instead; ShinRan fans wouldn't feel so THREATENED if Ai were a boy instead. It would also erase all false hope for Conan to be in another romance... so why make her a girl? What benefits do you have? Ai has haters [usually in the form of ShinRan] fans, mostly because other fans feel threatened that SHE will take Ran's place.
|
|
airgrimes
Little Detective
Death and the Sun? You can NEVER see them properly.
Posts: 24
|
Post by airgrimes on Sept 2, 2009 8:01:16 GMT -5
Just chillax.... The wruter has to bring in love rivals. look at NARUTO. Naruto likes Sakura, she liked Sasuke, Hinata likes Naruto. without that complicated mess NARUTO would probably have far less fans. anime's need love complications to bring in all kinds of fans. Shinichi will be with Ran. its just to keep fans on the edge of their seats a little, and to help anime-fillers.
ConanxAi is to draw in fans. you've merely become a fan of marketing stunt.
|
|
|
Post by shihoshinx on Oct 27, 2009 15:59:59 GMT -5
he is just bringing the reader's excitement.
also improving the knowledge about love.
I mean, a complicated love. (maybe...)
|
|
|
Post by adler1412 on Dec 11, 2009 23:31:05 GMT -5
I have one question Well, I am a new member. I don't know if somebody has asked this or not, but in DC#38, when Edogawa (Shinichi)was so close-he hid inside a locker in Kenbashi Station, he breathed so loud, I'm very sure! Then why Gin didn't realize somebody's there? Especially he had found Haibara hid in a fireplace only from her breathe. He could have found him, but looks like that he was thinking a bit before saying something like "it's impossible for adults to hide in there" and leave. Why? Gin also opened the lockers one by one but he stopped right at 'Edogawa's locker'?
|
|
|
Post by adler1412 on Dec 11, 2009 23:38:55 GMT -5
Well-for the age topic, I think that Vermouth uses her disguising skill to make her face looks younger-in vol 42 Akai mentioned it?
|
|
|
Post by adler1412 on Dec 11, 2009 23:41:31 GMT -5
I wonder, why does Vermouth look for Ai in a high school, not in an elementary school if she had known that? Ai --> a kid, I mean? (when she was disguising as Tomoaki Araide)
|
|
|
Post by Kentaru on Dec 12, 2009 6:13:47 GMT -5
1) I would argue that the comparison is not sound. That's why it won't add up. Gin has an obsessive relationship to Sherry (if in doubt, re-read #24). In Edogawa's case, it's different. He can probably hear the breathing, but the size of the locker makes it impossible for his Moriarty-like intellect to follow his deduction to its logic end: his equal is a toddler. That tells you a lot about Gin's character in very few lines.
2) Wrong. Re-read #42. Shuu specifically points out to Jodie that it -can't- be a face mask, since the bullet that grazed Vermouth's skin made her bleed.
3) Have a look at the pictures Vermouth keeps in her apartment: It's not Ai, but Sherry that she keeps throwing darts into. Hence, it probably took Vermouth a while to figure out what Sherry looks like now. The important thing to remember is: when did "Araide" know that Ai=Shiho? We can establish how she knew about Conan, but I don't remember when she learned about Shiho.There's only one way to know for sure: Try to re-read the fake Araide's appearances and Ai's in the same periods (from volume 25-ish till volume 41). Especially the stories where they actually meet before #42. But, to answer your question, she took over Araide's role because she didn't know that Shiho had shrunk at first. So she was looking for a high schooler instead of a kindergartener.
|
|
|
Post by kerubikun on Dec 29, 2009 4:32:16 GMT -5
-- Why doesn't Conan take those 24 hour pill that Haibara created? Being scientist, Haibara must have recorded how to make it, so she can create more. Conan could have turned back to Shinichi in safe time and go see Ran to make her stop worry.
-- What (or what do you think) was Shinichi going to tell to Ran in the sight-seeing resturant, if he hadn't turned back to Conan?
-- Why doesn't Vermouth tell Gin/Black Organization that Kudo Shinichi is alive as Edogawa Conan?
--It was Vermouth who was listening to the bug placed in Dr. Asaga(sp)'s house, right?
|
|
|
Post by Kentaru on Dec 30, 2009 7:02:09 GMT -5
1) I don't remember if the side effects were too hard on his body or if he becomes imune to these temporary antidotes after taking them once.
2) As the restaurant? It could be many things. Maybe that he loves her or that he's Conan too. But most likely he was going to propose to her. We know because his dad proposed to his mom there.
3) Conflicting interests. We can only guess, either the org is torn into two fractions or she's playing her own game. Either ways, she can't kill Shinichi or Ran (see their encounter in vol 35).
4) Yeah, she planted that bug in Agasa's house. Probably when the fake Araide paid a visit to Ai.
|
|
|
Post by adler1412 on Dec 30, 2009 22:22:32 GMT -5
Well, Edogawa can't take it, at least for now. Because if he takes it, it would be the end of Detective Conan.
|
|
imari
New Detective
Posts: 2
|
Post by imari on Jan 1, 2010 20:56:15 GMT -5
1) I don't remember if the side effects were too hard on his body or if he becomes imune to these temporary antidotes after taking them once. 2) As the restaurant? It could be many things. Maybe that he loves her or that he's Conan too. But most likely he was going to propose to her. We know because his dad proposed to his mom there. 3) Conflicting interests. We can only guess, either the org is torn into two fractions or she's playing her own game. Either ways, she can't kill Shinichi or Ran (see their encounter in vol 35). 4) Yeah, she planted that bug in Agasa's house. Probably when the fake Araide paid a visit to Ai. 1. His body becomes immune to it; as it treats the intrusion as if it were a cold. [ Watch the special- The Stranger in 10 Years. ] So, Shinichi would need a pill that would end up working in collaboration with his cells and genes. c: Besides, like Kerubikun said, Haibara-san has to record his happening so that she can make a more potent pill the next time. Of course, Shinichi is her guinea pig. :>
2. Which episode or chapter is this? Or is it the Special I mentioned preiviously?
3. I agree. I think Vermouth has her own plans as far as Shinichi goes. Maybe she'll use him as a guide to Sherry/Ai. Gin seems to be in charge of a lot, aside from the boss... being the boss, staying close to them could end up with her getting more than enough information that she could easily get on her own. She is very secretive, anyhow.
4. Sneaky, sneaky, Vermouth.
|
|
|
Post by heiji1993 on Jan 2, 2010 23:08:00 GMT -5
I don't know if this has been answered or not, but I've recently started wondering, when does Conan find out about the names Gin and Vodka? At first I assumed Harley (Heiji) told him (in the dubbed version episode 50 I think) and yet when I saw the subbed version of the same episode, He didn't mention them to him.
Also I wanted to know what Haibara's real dubbed name is. I hear that it's Anita Hailey, and yet from when I saw the dubbed movie, I hear that it is Vigray Thorn.
That is all I need to know, because I want to watch the episode of when Conan knew the truth and what to call Haibara in the English dub.
|
|
|
Post by faridsaputro on Jan 3, 2010 0:17:22 GMT -5
may I ask? --but the answer could only just for today, when and where sharon vineyard to meet with ran?
--Who's nickname of the new black organizations?
--in chapter how Shinichi allegedly lost his mind?
--who really killed his father jodie?
--whom the FBI spy who spied on black organizations?
--how Shuichi can escape from death?
|
|
|
Post by Kentaru on Jan 3, 2010 1:55:08 GMT -5
imari: No, I couldn't have been referring to the OAVs as they don't count in my book (They're never mentioned again in the manga and Aoyama didn't write them, so they might as well be AU fanfics). In answer #1, I actually meant the epilogues of the story arcs in vol10 and vol26. heiji1993: That's what happens when you watch "Case Closed" instead of the original. The anime crew changed the early MIB appearances into random villain arcs, so that created some plot holes (they didn't know how long the manga would last). In the anime, it's never explained how he learns their nicknames... However, in vol.4 of the manga, Conan overheard the MIB's nicknames on the bullet train to Osaka thanks to one of Agasa's bugs. Ai's real name's Shiho Miyano and you really need to watch the fansubs or, preferably, read the scanslation, because the dub's a travesty. @farid: I'll answer the questions I understood (I'm sorry, but half of them make no sense in English). Sharon Vineyard and Ran met in vol35. Vermouth killed Jodie's father and burned his house down to erase all the evidence that the FBI had been gathering on her. Shuuichi was in the organization for some time as an undercover FBI mole. Last question--> I'll give you a hint: the police said that the prints on Conan's cell matched the corpse, right? Well, suppose someone else in the hospital touched Conan's cell... When you can answer that question, read:
|
|